We have been asked to reflect on our greatest challenge with Action Research, and for me it is clear--in the middle of a job change, with a myriad of possibilities to focus on, I have had my biggest struggles related to issues of identity. I had a goal to change my role when I joined the program, and looked toward a time, a year out that I would have to accomplish that change.
My job suddenly "went away" in early November, with a host of issues that made it unusually challenging for me to move on. My expertise and community connections, as well as my research interest, had been focused around the old job. How would I focus my research without continuing to play that role?
I decided to choose one community where I could continue to work as a volunteer in order to do my research. Many of the project leaders appreciated my continued assistance, and encouraged me to engage as a volunteer/researcher throughout the remainder of the year.
But the project has been plagued by political difficulties, changes in leadership, and poor execution, and all of these issues have created an anxiety in me that increased my self-doubt related to the role I played, especially in connection to the math teachers and students I most wanted to see grow from my work. I began to take steps to "decrease the gap" between the math teachers and I. I took and passed the CBEST, interviewed for a teaching fellowship and took and passed the CSET for middle school math. But as I kept getting closer to actually becoming a teacher, I didn't grow any closer or more successful with the teachers in the research project.
I keep asking myself whether I have what it takes to be a teacher, and whether I really want to teach children or adults. In the context of these struggles, I get an opportunity to interview for a job that seems to blend the old and the new--an account management position for a company that doesn't actually sell anything (they have a free product that I would represent). I intuitively go for this job and every step brings me closer to what I now call "my dream job". But looking at my steps related to action research, I keep thinking, how will I finish my project? Am I abandoning the process I started? Did I fail at this?
But I wouldn't be where I am now if not for my Action Research. I wouldn't have even known about this technology or company if I didn't go out and research various tools to build trusted communities on the web.
I am confident that this role will be a good fit for me, especially after spending my first two days on the job. It seems that I can almost finish my boss's sentences, and we are delighted to be working toward shared goals and passions.
Sunday, April 10, 2011
Friday, March 11, 2011
Cycle One and Tworl
This last couple of weeks, I have been intently focused on issues of identity and future. My Cycle One report is submitted, and I am anxiously awaiting response. The activity level, acceptance feedback and additional opportunities from my Cycle activities are exciting. Yet, I still find myself spending inordinate time on questions of future career direction, and whether or not I should be jumping all the way into becoming a math teacher.
I am really good at helping people with technology, yet I have a huge "hill to climb" as it relates to becoming a math expert. Yet the community that I most want to be a part of is the math community. Do I have to become a classroom teacher to make this happen?
It seems as thought there are not enough hours in the day to successfully re-learn the math I once knew in order to pass the CSET exams. I have attended 2 study sessions in Oakland and done numerous individual practice sets. It still seems as though the mastery required is well beyond me at this point. Tomorrow is the big test, and I am still in the swirling clouds of wondering if I really have to do this. Of course, as I got up this morning in the early hours to study, I see a job opportunity at the company I have most closely followed in the last couple of months...
I recall the book from Carol Dweck on Mindset, and resolve to keep executing my plan and process, with a growth mindset. I do not know what my future will bring, but learning this math will bring me closer to my esteemed colleagues. I continue on...
I am really good at helping people with technology, yet I have a huge "hill to climb" as it relates to becoming a math expert. Yet the community that I most want to be a part of is the math community. Do I have to become a classroom teacher to make this happen?
It seems as thought there are not enough hours in the day to successfully re-learn the math I once knew in order to pass the CSET exams. I have attended 2 study sessions in Oakland and done numerous individual practice sets. It still seems as though the mastery required is well beyond me at this point. Tomorrow is the big test, and I am still in the swirling clouds of wondering if I really have to do this. Of course, as I got up this morning in the early hours to study, I see a job opportunity at the company I have most closely followed in the last couple of months...
I recall the book from Carol Dweck on Mindset, and resolve to keep executing my plan and process, with a growth mindset. I do not know what my future will bring, but learning this math will bring me closer to my esteemed colleagues. I continue on...
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Identity, Separation, Steps to Participate More Fully
For about the last 4 weeks, I have been taking a set of explicit steps to fix an issue that is inhibiting my success in building a CoP for my Action Research. I am not quite sure how far this should take me, but it is an exciting and intimidating set of actions.
In my first Cycle, I have been working to become a more integrated member of the local Math community, with an eye toward building my own online CoP. In order to become as close to this community as possible, I have taken several steps toward becoming a teacher. I took and passed the CBEST test, so that I can sub as a math teacher right away. I have interviewed for the Oakland Teaching Fellows program, with an eye toward becoming a fully credentialed math teacher. I am studying for the CSET exams, the very demanding mathematics certification requirement for all secondary math teachers in CA.
It is intimidating to me to consider making a change of this magnitude in my life, but I continue to follow the steps that are emerging from my learning within action research. There is a magnitude to the application of my learning in this respect that feels just incredibly daunting. In sitting through a tutoring session related to the CSET, I was rapidly taken through key aspects of linear algebra, I felt as though I must have forgotten more than I remembered. But as the instructor led us through several well designed sample problems, I began to remember and re-master the procedures. It is doubtful that I will pass the CSET in my first try. Only 30% of test takers pass. This test is designed to "weed out" those that should not be teaching math.
But how effective is it at that task? I see examples every day of the significant gap between success and failure in the math classroom. Our CST test scores show that a majority of students are behind the state mandated pace. Our comparisons with other states and countries show that there is substantial room for growth.
Maybe, if I can pass the CSET, I can model, through my own teaching, students and practices, what it takes to succeed. Maybe I should be focused on just this sort of measurement of my own success.
It will be very interesting to see what opportunities I am prepared for and able to move forward with once I complete my studies and research. In the meantime, I am committed to the process.
In my first Cycle, I have been working to become a more integrated member of the local Math community, with an eye toward building my own online CoP. In order to become as close to this community as possible, I have taken several steps toward becoming a teacher. I took and passed the CBEST test, so that I can sub as a math teacher right away. I have interviewed for the Oakland Teaching Fellows program, with an eye toward becoming a fully credentialed math teacher. I am studying for the CSET exams, the very demanding mathematics certification requirement for all secondary math teachers in CA.
It is intimidating to me to consider making a change of this magnitude in my life, but I continue to follow the steps that are emerging from my learning within action research. There is a magnitude to the application of my learning in this respect that feels just incredibly daunting. In sitting through a tutoring session related to the CSET, I was rapidly taken through key aspects of linear algebra, I felt as though I must have forgotten more than I remembered. But as the instructor led us through several well designed sample problems, I began to remember and re-master the procedures. It is doubtful that I will pass the CSET in my first try. Only 30% of test takers pass. This test is designed to "weed out" those that should not be teaching math.
But how effective is it at that task? I see examples every day of the significant gap between success and failure in the math classroom. Our CST test scores show that a majority of students are behind the state mandated pace. Our comparisons with other states and countries show that there is substantial room for growth.
Maybe, if I can pass the CSET, I can model, through my own teaching, students and practices, what it takes to succeed. Maybe I should be focused on just this sort of measurement of my own success.
It will be very interesting to see what opportunities I am prepared for and able to move forward with once I complete my studies and research. In the meantime, I am committed to the process.
Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Here are some raw notes for Action Research.
During the month of January, I worked most on building community through in person activities. This month will be the month I start doing a rigorous amount of surveying and posting of online resources such as these webcasts.
I am including them here as a way to visualize my work through writing. It seems a bit of a mess right now, with various efforts and activities spread out throughout my computer and my life. As I begin to formalize my Cycle 1 writeup and plan for Cycle 2, these things will take shape.
Aaaahhh, to be in the creative and learning process. So hard and so fun.
Goal: Build credibility as way to build community. Contribute meaningful content to SSFUSD After School Homework Center Learning Community and see if I can attract an online CoP.
Activity 1: Attend MDTP Data Analysis Workshop with team, RAFT training and Lesson Study with Math teachers from SSFUSD.
Date: 1/6 3:30-5pm Met 8 teachers and assisted Emilano Gomez from UC Berkeley with MDTP Data Analysis Workshop. Shared with teachers that they may want to author their own questions as well as using MDTP items, and offered to follow-up. Learned that a few classes may have taken an MDTP test that was not "on-level" for their students, as the student's scored less than 15% on average, which they might have scored just by guessing on test items. Offered to help with training on building test items using Daskala. Teachers seemed somewhat overwhelmed and nervous about upcoming start to Homework Centers.
Date 1/8 9am - 5pm. Attended half day of RAFT training led by Jeanne Lazarrini. Learned how activity kits are constructed, and how they can be used to support flexible understandings of math that build conceptual foundations that help with longer term success.
Date 1/27 9:15am - 3:45pm. Attended SVMI Lesson Study. Participated with 4 SSFUSD teachers and SMCOE Math Coordinator April Cherrington in review of 1 well constructed 6th grade lesson. Created new dialogue with SSFUSD District Math Coach which will be helpful in Homework Center project.
1/31: Discussed status with Zubin Koshy regarding upcoming meeting with Principal of Alta Loma MS in SSF. Came up with examples for him to use in meeting with CST Questions that could be linked via Daskala for Pre/Post testing.
2/8: Sent detailed webcast info to HC leadership team illustrating Daskala delivered CST quizzes linked to RAFT activity kits. Over next few days, worked with Jeanne Lazarrini of RAFT to finetune.
Jeanne Lazzarini to Anne, Robert, me, Greg, Josephine, One, Ana
show details 12:59 PM (1 hour ago)
Hi Jill! After my review, here are my suggestions. For Head to 100, I would leave out questions # 1 and # 11, but keep all the others. For Flip Over Fractions, your demo did not show the questions (it only showed answers) for questions number 2, 3, 5, and 6, so I wasn’t sure how apply for the grade levels. However, for grade 2, I would not include question # 1 at this point, but I would include questions 8, 9, 10, and 13 so far. For grades 3 and 4 I would include questions 1, 4, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19. Then, for Meet My Function Machine, I suggest like you do that the questions be split into appropriate grade levels. So, for the lower grades (grades 3, 4, and 5) I would use the following questions: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 (not question # 1). For the upper grades (grades 7 and 8) I suggest you leave off questions 12, 13, 14, 19, and 20 because other questions are similar. I do suggest for grades 7 & 8 you use questions 1, 8, 9, 10, 11, 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, and 22. Let me know your thoughts !!!! I hope this is of help! Take care! J Jeanne L
During the month of January, I worked most on building community through in person activities. This month will be the month I start doing a rigorous amount of surveying and posting of online resources such as these webcasts.
I am including them here as a way to visualize my work through writing. It seems a bit of a mess right now, with various efforts and activities spread out throughout my computer and my life. As I begin to formalize my Cycle 1 writeup and plan for Cycle 2, these things will take shape.
Aaaahhh, to be in the creative and learning process. So hard and so fun.
Goal: Build credibility as way to build community. Contribute meaningful content to SSFUSD After School Homework Center Learning Community and see if I can attract an online CoP.
Activity 1: Attend MDTP Data Analysis Workshop with team, RAFT training and Lesson Study with Math teachers from SSFUSD.
Date: 1/6 3:30-5pm Met 8 teachers and assisted Emilano Gomez from UC Berkeley with MDTP Data Analysis Workshop. Shared with teachers that they may want to author their own questions as well as using MDTP items, and offered to follow-up. Learned that a few classes may have taken an MDTP test that was not "on-level" for their students, as the student's scored less than 15% on average, which they might have scored just by guessing on test items. Offered to help with training on building test items using Daskala. Teachers seemed somewhat overwhelmed and nervous about upcoming start to Homework Centers.
Date 1/8 9am - 5pm. Attended half day of RAFT training led by Jeanne Lazarrini. Learned how activity kits are constructed, and how they can be used to support flexible understandings of math that build conceptual foundations that help with longer term success.
Date 1/27 9:15am - 3:45pm. Attended SVMI Lesson Study. Participated with 4 SSFUSD teachers and SMCOE Math Coordinator April Cherrington in review of 1 well constructed 6th grade lesson. Created new dialogue with SSFUSD District Math Coach which will be helpful in Homework Center project.
1/31: Discussed status with Zubin Koshy regarding upcoming meeting with Principal of Alta Loma MS in SSF. Came up with examples for him to use in meeting with CST Questions that could be linked via Daskala for Pre/Post testing.
2/8: Sent detailed webcast info to HC leadership team illustrating Daskala delivered CST quizzes linked to RAFT activity kits. Over next few days, worked with Jeanne Lazarrini of RAFT to finetune.
Jeanne Lazzarini to Anne, Robert, me, Greg, Josephine, One, Ana
show details 12:59 PM (1 hour ago)
Hi Jill! After my review, here are my suggestions. For Head to 100, I would leave out questions # 1 and # 11, but keep all the others. For Flip Over Fractions, your demo did not show the questions (it only showed answers) for questions number 2, 3, 5, and 6, so I wasn’t sure how apply for the grade levels. However, for grade 2, I would not include question # 1 at this point, but I would include questions 8, 9, 10, and 13 so far. For grades 3 and 4 I would include questions 1, 4, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19. Then, for Meet My Function Machine, I suggest like you do that the questions be split into appropriate grade levels. So, for the lower grades (grades 3, 4, and 5) I would use the following questions: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 (not question # 1). For the upper grades (grades 7 and 8) I suggest you leave off questions 12, 13, 14, 19, and 20 because other questions are similar. I do suggest for grades 7 & 8 you use questions 1, 8, 9, 10, 11, 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, and 22. Let me know your thoughts !!!! I hope this is of help! Take care! J Jeanne L
Monday, January 31, 2011
Identity, Initial Steps in AR
Alot of my work over the month of January has centered around identity - how am I defining myself in the context of a new role and new research? Many people with whom I have worked over the last 18 months are still barely cognizant of my change in status from working at Daskala to researching myself. As I begin to construct my email intro to a survey and invitation for collaboration, I continue to consider so many aspects of this move.
When we read and discuss Frank Smith, we think of "joining the club" as being an element of Community of Practice (CoP). During the last 60 days, I have tried hard to attend events, in person, where I can become a member of the club. I am trying to understand the norms, people, practices and areas of web focus, so that my online CoP can become effectively integrated within these potential groups of collaborators:
California Education Research Association
California Math Council
Silicon Valley Community Foundation Math Learning Cohort
Silicon Valley Math Initiative
SSFUSD After School Homework Center
What specifically will I do? How will I engage with others? What qualifications do I have that would lead me to expect that this will be of value to others? I am reading Carol Dweck's Mindset and one of the powerful transitions that is going on with me is a shift from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset. I think one of the main areas I can contribute, will be to add my "screencast" resources to those easily found on the web. Kind of a "here's how I understand this" and then with a link to surveys that can help me track data associated with my research.
Another link that I would like to make, is to send out a screencast that includes an invitation to a survey that helps me understand key ways that they like to process information: which websites they use as resources, and when, which areas that reteaching and re-engagement strategies or full lesson plans and lesson studies might be effective. This might be part of my next cycle.
It is interesting to note that my initial Grou.ps website is getting absolutely no traction right now. The last update I made before changing roles and platform are the last updates. Maybe this can be a reference point for comparison in the future.
When we read and discuss Frank Smith, we think of "joining the club" as being an element of Community of Practice (CoP). During the last 60 days, I have tried hard to attend events, in person, where I can become a member of the club. I am trying to understand the norms, people, practices and areas of web focus, so that my online CoP can become effectively integrated within these potential groups of collaborators:
California Education Research Association
California Math Council
Silicon Valley Community Foundation Math Learning Cohort
Silicon Valley Math Initiative
SSFUSD After School Homework Center
What specifically will I do? How will I engage with others? What qualifications do I have that would lead me to expect that this will be of value to others? I am reading Carol Dweck's Mindset and one of the powerful transitions that is going on with me is a shift from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset. I think one of the main areas I can contribute, will be to add my "screencast" resources to those easily found on the web. Kind of a "here's how I understand this" and then with a link to surveys that can help me track data associated with my research.
Another link that I would like to make, is to send out a screencast that includes an invitation to a survey that helps me understand key ways that they like to process information: which websites they use as resources, and when, which areas that reteaching and re-engagement strategies or full lesson plans and lesson studies might be effective. This might be part of my next cycle.
It is interesting to note that my initial Grou.ps website is getting absolutely no traction right now. The last update I made before changing roles and platform are the last updates. Maybe this can be a reference point for comparison in the future.
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Notes and Resources for AR Plan
Here is a great resource that I am going to have to think about.
http://math247.pbworks.com/w/page/20517573/Mathcasts%20-%20Pencasts%20-%20LiveScribe%20SmartPen#CreatingMathcastsUsingtheLiveScribeSmartPen
I've started using my own livescribe pen, and would love to be able to integrate this easy to use, easy to navigate type of resource in my online PLC.
Noted here, I will come back to this.
http://math247.pbworks.com/w/page/20517573/Mathcasts%20-%20Pencasts%20-%20LiveScribe%20SmartPen#CreatingMathcastsUsingtheLiveScribeSmartPen
I've started using my own livescribe pen, and would love to be able to integrate this easy to use, easy to navigate type of resource in my online PLC.
Noted here, I will come back to this.
Monday, January 10, 2011
Action Research - Executing the Plan
The plan for my Action Research is taking shape, classes are beginning again, yet I am pausing before my deep dive, in large part because of questions related to role and identity.One of the key challenges that I will address moving forward, is the changed role that I play within the community of professionals that I have engaged with for the last many months. I feel as though I need to build upon the certainty, the messaging, and the "teaching" that I will do, as I re-introduce myself to friends and colleagues.
Inviting associates to an online community dialogue is more daunting than just sending an email with a change of contact info. "Hello, I am no longer with Daskala, now I am studying and doing research at Pepperdine, and I'd like to continue our dialogue, but now with a research foundation, and intentional, Action Research objective, rather than a corporate, tool delivery objective..." Ok, that is hard, and perhaps a little lame...I've got to do better, be more concise, more illustrative in my communications. Maybe technology itself can help me. I found this wordle application that can help with powerful text images. Maybe this is one additional tool for my online PLC, or Virtual Learning Community.
Hopefully my readings, projects and assignments will continue to lead me in directions I can build upon.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)