Thursday, December 16, 2010

Final Reflections of the Semester

It is starting to look and feel good to be done with the last 12 weeks of progressive learning on AR, Cognitive Tools and Design Principles. One claim that I can make about this program is that it has sure given me the confidence to learn and build with new tools effectively.

When we started in summer, I had NEVER built a website, blogged, or even kept a journal. Building the "habit of mind" to consistently blog has been a challenge for me, but within the context of all that we are doing, I realize how important and beneficial this is, so here we are!

This week, I learned how to build a Google Site for the first time, in order to entirely replace my AR Website, since the earlier version I learned and built, was destroyed by the team at Grou.ps when they started charging for their web services (ok, not entirely destroyed, just lost the look and feel I worked so hard on, with a bunch of cheesy advertising replacing my customized version).

On Monday, with the help of new resources I had learned about through my coursework and teammates, I build my new site in just a few hours. https://sites.google.com/a/pepperdine.edu/jill-s-malt-site/ Then, using a new tool from Adobe, discovered and endorsed by my learning circle friends, I created a new version of my Lit Review. https://acrobat.com/app.html#d=PD5hicDAbc23EGFvrWwUvA If this pace keeps up, I'll have to have a separate page on my resume, just to list the tools I have proficiency in!

As I look back on the progress of my learning, I really appreciate the readings, challenges, and especially the opportunity to do my research in such a supportive environment. I still struggle, sometimes, with the format, and find myself craving real "face-to-face" collaboration. In conjunction with my AR, I have recently attended 2 conferences, and an important local "learning cohort" meeting. These events have tremendous value in bringing alive the people behind the work that we do so much now over the web. At the CA Education Research Association, I met several important players, including one person that I may launch a new organization with. At the CA Math Council, I got to hear a live talk from one of my most inspiring authors that I encountered during my Lit Review, Professor Jo Boaler, who is now back at Stanford. I find it incredibly intriguing to hear the thoughts of others as they articulate where the "next steps" are in a number of challenging areas where they are regarded as expert.

One presenter, David Foster, is working hard on new assessments for the Common Core Standards, and I am inspired by his approach, as well as his optimism that the Common Core might help students and teachers quite profoundly. This will likely be an important topic for my AR work to parallel, and to connect with, in order to ride the momentum of others who have similar goals and aspirations that I do.

Another presenter, Rick Miller, spoke eloquently of the new Brokers of Expertise portal, and this makes me want to take a leading role in developing a presence on that platform, as it will likely be a topic of discussion and a common tool for many potential collaborators that I envision working with.

Another group discussion that I participated in at CMC/Asilomar focused heavily on what universities can do to support a newly designated Teacher Certification in Math, and I found my readings and work in AR to be an important "baseline" for participating and even understanding the dialogue amongst them as it relates to appropriate activities for a Masters program.

One issue that I am left continually wondering about--how far should I be taking this new identity of mine? Will I find that being a full time graduate student and researcher suits me? Will this lead to new career opportunities where I can more fully exploit the new habits of mind that I am building? It was this time last year that I was becoming fixed on doing this graduate work. As I flash forward, and try now to predict my expected outcomes for the spring term and the pace of my projects in AR and Design, I can't help but wonder whether another semester and change will do it.

I am enjoying this "hard fun" and hope that my activities in the upcoming weeks will continue to build upon the value that is taking hold.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Design Strand - Interesting look back at notes

Here are my notes to team on 8/1. Now that we have circled back to this original idea, and are all on board with moving ahead on this learning problem, it is interesting to reflect back to where we were at that time. Now that I have the benefit of much reading, a full cycle on our first learning problem, it should be fairly straightforward to move through the phases of refining our second cycle design problem--the AR website.

https://sites.google.com/site/arcrunchprototype1/

We went through an entire cycle of problem definition and tools auditions on a different problem, but the "promisingness" of that idea started to look a little less rosy to teammates in mid-November, so we are back to our original, with more resolve and justification.

To team, via email:

Here are some thoughts of mine:

I think a product that we would design should have some basic criteria that makes it great to work on as a team. Here are some starting points, please add to:

1. solves a big problem (large market, brings value to alot of people)
2. can be solved elegantly, simply
3. we as a team have an expertise that gives us a strong competitive differentiation from other solutions out there
4. our work on this helps us learn better and work together better in our MALT coursework
5. gets bigger with more time - leads to more opportunities to do what we want in the future

If I go through my brainstorms, as well as those I've heard so far, here are some opening thoughts on how our suggested ideas might work against these criteria:

Action Research DVD

1. by definition, helps improve practice, knowledge and social value (just got my books, I've even started reading!)
Some other stuff out there:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/24832986/Action-Research-A-Learning-Tool-That-Engages-Complexity
http://web.gc.cuny.edu/che/projectmf.htm
http://teachingtoday.glencoe.com/howtoarticles/teacher-as-researcher-taking-action-research-to-task
2. we demonstrated already our capacity to create a dvd, we can only get better, with our ever increasing knowledge of various learning tools, could get even better
3. same here, we'll only get better. having a project/product to design will give us stronger understanding of AR as we move forward
4. by definition, we meet this criteria
5. ??? What do you guys think?

Web 2.0/Group Website for Challenge Success

1. I can talk more about this, but this speaks to a huge need out there, all over the place. Schools and families have swung too far in one direction, overscheduling and overstressing kids to try to prepare them for a bright future precisely at the time when the world is changing in such a way as to make these kinds of activities counterproductive. If we were to do something using "THE TOOLS of AR and MALT" that links the the growing Challenge Success movement, it will help grow the prestige of ourselves, our program, (in my humble opinion)
2. I see some ideas here that may work, open to other notions that you all may have
3. This is primarily a face to face type of workshop movement, we could become experts in the online delivery methodology
4.
5. I've seen this continue to grow, get bigger and bigger, we could add alot of value here, I think

Another Idea - Fraction Rap website
I talked about this a little at the campfire--just a dream of mine--to take the natural, catchiness of music and rhythm in order to make a big dent in the educational problem that keeps a ton of kids from progressing successfully into college. My idea would be to set up a Grou.ps website like ours and maybe set up a challenge with starters and then a competition. Have people (kids, schools, classes, musicians) come up with rhymes that could be performed against catchy backgrounds and uploaded to youtube to help kids understand fractions conceptually a whole lot better.

Listen to this tune a few times and a guarantee that "like an ipod stuck on rewind, rewind...) will be ringing in your head a few days. What if we could replace that rhyme with something that helps kids with math?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZoG5jJ3E8rg

1. This is a huge need, based on my work, probably the number one thing in all of the US that if you could solve it, a ton more kids are successful in school and on the path to college
2. I think so, what do you think?
3. all our MALT skills could be leveraged...learning and technology together
4. I think so, what do you think?
5. If we did this, we'd for sure go viral...not sure if that is a goal, but I like it...

Check out Mr. Duey for some other ideas. He makes a nice start, but I think we could do so much better!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V96_PjlrVQc

Monday, November 29, 2010

Changing my CoP

So it has been a couple of weeks since I've been posting. I've been pretty pre-occupied by a major shift in my employment situation, one in which I'll be moving on from my startup job into that of a full time student role (for at least a while...) There are countless issues that could be related to this change in the context of my MALT classes, but I've been hesitant to post, as I've been negotiating with the executives of my former company, and there are many uncertainties about what kind of confidentiality agreement I am going to have to sign.

Over the last few days, it appears that our negotiations will be complete, without alot of excessive "legal-ese" so I feel a weight off my shoulders, and feel free again to reflect on my own learning process.

Two key issues that have swirled around my thoughts over the last few weeks have to do with identity and trust. The trust issues have been a challenge for me, and are likely best not shared in this format, but those related to my identity and role are probably quite relevant.

I started working for this small company over a year ago, and have been engaged heavily in efforts to expand the use and knowledge of their innovative teacher support tools, but much of this has been done with an eye toward the future, and a more "expert" role that I would like to play. I have built relationships with approximately 25 instructional leaders who are implementing the new capabilities. The technology is fairly straightforward, but the learning process, and change process within the school environments, is one that requires time. It will be important to me, personally, and in light of what I am learning about how to be a good collaborator, and how important that is in support of social learning, that I maintain a good rapport, and effective communications with many of these contacts.

I faced a major transition point 2 weeks ago, when I began to tell my colleagues about my impending change. Some worried, as they had begun to rely on my personal involvement, and my determination that this technology would support the change they were working toward. In many ways, helping people understand the goals I am pursuing, as part of the Pepperdine program, is the beginning of my AR Cycle 1. It is also fascinating to explore the way it changes my own social learning construct. I am really looking forward to finalizing my Lit Review and AR plan, so that I can share it with my recent (and hopefully future) collaborators.

The emails I have thus far received, have been full of well wishes, interest and a few ringing endorsements. One particularly meaningful response was from one of my university collaborators..."Thank you for letting us know of the change in your position. Your new project looks like a natural successor to your work with us; I am glad that more people will be able to learn about the importance of formative assessment, assessment, professional learning communities, and the relations among them. I know that you will bring rich hands-on experience to this study."

This type of feedback is very encouraging as I begin the important work in my AR cycles. As Margaret mentioned the other day, sometimes focusing on the areas which are "least secure" can prove the most fruitful. The email I sent out to all, which generated this response, was a very important, and reassuring step.

It is posted here, as an important artifact of my efforts...

Greetings from Palo Alto.



I am contacting you to let you know of a transition out of my recent role at "D" into that of "full-time student" at Pepperdine University, and to share with you my new contact information.



I am embarking on a new Action Research project related to formative testing, technology and professional learning communities in conjunction with the Graduate program in Learning Technology at Pepperdine.



I will continue to be heavily interested in the success of projects that have begun to leverage "D's" technology in support of student achievement, and would be delighted to assist in any transition issues that will make working with the team at "D", led by CEO SB, even more productive. SB will also be in touch with key company contact information and instructions for continued delivery of "D's" services. Any questions can be directed to support@"d".com

Please begin using this Pepperdine email as a primary way to reach me, along with my direct cell number listed below.



Thanks to all of you, especially the good friends at MDTP, for the exciting work that we have engaged in together. I am confident that there will be many opportunities to collaborate in the future, and I look forward to hearing from you in the near term.

Warm regards,
Jill
(with contact info excluded)

Saturday, October 30, 2010

Review of the Literature Sure Helps with AR Ideas

Wow! It sure is amazing to do a deep dive into the literature on my potential topic areas. I feel flush with ideas, and inspired by my new level of understanding about the challenges being worked all around me.

I fell energized, yet pressured to get everything into a working, high quality first draft. If I am reflective enough, perhaps I will stumble onto some new insights into my own cognitive process.

I find myself wishing again for a less remote group of classroom collaborators. Sure would be nice to talk through this face to face over a cup of coffee with one of my learning circle...

Friday, October 22, 2010

My role in reforming math

I am not a mathematician, a teacher, a salesman, a principal or school leader. I am an ambitious person who wants more for the children around me who struggle with math, and feel that I may be uniquely qualified to lead a process that helps to invigorate the model for fixing problems related to funding successful school learning problems.

I have worked in the area of school decision making for over 20 years. From this vantage point, and with a fairly confident understanding of problem solving, systems thinking and technical communications, I may be able to do something that helps to unlock the logjam of school improvement, especially for students who deserve the right to inspiring lessons about real world math.

I believe that one of the problems in bringing more rigorous math and consistently high quality math experiences to kids is the lack of an "ROI" model that really works to support the changes that may help. The trial and error process involved in most changes and school reforms is rarely re-evaluated after decisions to try something new are pursued. Alot of research gets done, but most evidence of student achievement ends up pointing back to easy to access data such as once/year summative assessments.

To bring new light to this problem, I'll be working to create a larger body of evidence and data points that support a new type of "baseline" and communications around how leaders evaluate whether their math investments in teachers, tools and strategies are working well for students. This Action Research may not fit within the span of time that I have available during my MALT program at Pepperdine, but it is worthwhile enough that I aim to tackle the issue anyway.

In her book "What's Math Got to Do With It?" Jo Boaler makes a compelling point for dramatically changing the way we view mathematics and bring it into children's lives. "Math has many things to answer for and this book is all about giving parents and others the knowledge of good ways to work in schools and homes, so that we can start improving our children's and our country's futures." P. 11

I believe that this approach has great promise, and that if combined with the innovative technology tools for real-time assessment, as well as rigorous and effective strategies for enhancing problem based learning through explicit encouragement of "...students to ask questions, to represent, reason, and generalize, and to share and think about different methods.." we may land upon school improvement effort that actually scales.

If this can be demonstrated, Federal I3 grant money is available, and perhaps we can tap into the massive cognitive surplus that exists in the large number of students who hate math because they don't get it.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Swimming with Ideas about Communities of Practice

Well, my husband's injury has put me somewhat behind in ALL of my MALT assignments, but it has also given me an interesting perspective on a Community of Practice that I never knew existed. In Inyo County, they have a volunteer search and rescue group that performs an extraordinary service. This dedicated group rescued my husband from an area so remote that it took several hours of treacherous hiking/backpacking even to pack out and reach out for help.

When I heard the stories of the team of 18 people who trekked up the mountain, beginning at 8:30pm last Saturday night, I could only imagine the way this group must work together, learn together and do amazing things. I tried to look them up online, and they have no public web presence, which gave me the idea that perhaps our design team should help to build an online celebration of their good work, with an eye toward helping fundraise for their work in the future.

Not having been part of this trip, I was unable to meet them in person and observe their work, so this group did not make sense for my CoP Ethnography. But maybe it could be something that interests the other members of my team? With all the cuts in state funding for parks and recreation, maybe they need some online helpers like our Design Team?

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Projects, Process and Real Life

This is a week that has been filled with a variety of ups and downs in my research, work and life.

We have completed an important group project in the design strand, submitted a newly framed AR problem statement and progressed on our CoP ethnography. Balancing has never been so difficult for me, as my husband has suffered through an emergency accident on a remote backpacking trip, requiring a midnight search and rescue team, ambulance, hospital, and now surgery. My reliance on him for support and stability as I "multi-task" my job and graduate studies is gone in an instant. But at least he will ultimately be ok, our family unit will be intact again. Many are not so lucky, so blessed with the resources, strength and survival tools when they have faced similarly bleak situations.

The many hours spent waiting on doctors and hospitals affords me the opportunity to read and re-read. I am really enjoying the book "Surpassing Ourselves," especially as it relates so directly to my reason for going to graduate school--a long term career shift from business development to "expert/consultant." In many ways, this reading resonates with my own experience. My instincts for finding new and successful technology solutions for teachers is increasingly close to "expert" vs. "experienced non-expert" in the parlance of Bereiter and Scardamalia.

The evidence of this is found in the many successful teachers and researchers that I engage with, not just the "numbers" of newly signed customers. This is important, because some risky, high profile, low-profit work that I encouraged our company to take on this summer is becoming a high volume, highly anticipated research project for WestEd this fall. Later this week, my CEO will reference this work in a meeting with the newly appointed Deputy Superintendent of Schools for CA, Gino Flores.

If things go well, we will be working at even higher scale, with higher possibility of positive impact than before. I hope this can inform my AR in a positive way.