Monday, September 6, 2010

The Book of Learning and Forgetting

I'm really enjoying the Frank Smith book, but if you follow his arguments for the classical view of learning, it brings up many questions about how you might ideally structure the organization and funding model for schools. One of the newer roles I see assessment playing in the official learning model (today's school systems) is that of helping to determine what kinds of investments and activities drive the desired outcomes, so that more programmatic support can be directed to those activities. I know that alot of the business world around us comes down to measurements of financial success, a bottom line. Is there no way to construct a more appropriate bottom line for schools? Perhaps some way to place a value on the "learning without forgetting" possibilities that could be derived from a classic model?

His approach seems intuitively attractive, but it is very difficult to imagine the kind of investments required to support a completely open ended, non-tested school situation. Are there charter schools, and home schools that have begun testing this approach? What are the characteristics of the learning that occurs there?

The ideal school would seem to hinge upon what kinds of "clubs" might be constructed to organize the projects and absorbing activities that Smith envisions. I wonder if he has ever been very actively involved in real school reform?

1 comment:

  1. Frank Smith is an idealist poking holes at the hard work that is done in schools but he also speaks the truth where many remain silent. When he says "club" read community of practice. Can kids be a part of a community of practice? Are they really members of the community. Or sort of apprentices working with distant masters? What would school be like if this was really the case? What if kids were for hire but it was up to schools to make sure that they were engaged in service learning? Does that scare you? Should it? What does it mean to have students isolated from the pressures of the workplace? Is this a good thing? What are the downsides? What might we do to make kids more a part of the club?

    ReplyDelete